Access to Information Request – Canada’s OPCAT Consultation Process 2019?

In November 2018 the UN Committee against Torture examined Canada’s seventh periodic report in Geneva, Switzerland, issuing a set of key recommendations in a document dated 21 December 2018.

Among the UN Committee’s numerous recommendations was that Canada should:

(d) Complete the process towards accession to the Optional Protocol to the Convention, while introducing mechanisms to ensure the participation of civil society, indigenous groups and other stakeholders in the entire process.

Please see paragraph 21(d) of the Concluding observations on the seventh periodic report of Canada (UN Doc. CAT/C/CAN/CO/7) for more detailed information.

But what has happened in practice regarding the recommended consultation process with civil society, indigenous groups and other stakeholders since December 2018? The Canada OPCAT Project asked this simple question in an Access to Information and Privacy Request (ATIP Request) filed with Global Affairs Canada on 23 December 2019.

Information by Alexander Svensson (14 October 2010).

The Canada OPCAT Project lodged the following ATIP Request:

In its Concluding Observations in relation to Canada’s 7th periodic report under the UN Convention against Torture, the UN Committee against Torture recommended that Canada should:

(d) Complete the process towards accession to the Optional Protocol to the Convention, while introducing mechanisms to ensure the participation of civil society, indigenous groups and other stakeholders in the entire process.

In view of this key United Nations recommendation, please provide copies of any written communications such as letters and emails with Canadian civil society organizations and National Indigenous Organizations on the question of accession by Canada to the Optional Protocol to the UN Convention against Torture since 1 December 2018 to the 21 December 2019.

Please also provide copies of any backgrounders, briefing notes, presentations or other relevant documents for discussion with Canadian civil society organizations and National Indigenous Organizations on the question of Canada acceding to the Optional Protocol to the UN Convention against Torture.

Upon official receipt, Global Affairs Canada has 30 calendar-days to process this request, unless it asks for an extension in order to be able to do so.

Information by Damian Gadal (1 March 2015).

Frequent visitors to the Canada OPCAT Project website will recall that our past attempts to prise open information about the OPCAT consultation process from the Federal Government have been – at best – highly unsuccessful.

An Access to Information and Privacy Request from June 2018 to obtain a copy of a Justice Canada-led legal analysis on accession to the OPCAT resulted in reams of withheld information and page-upon-page of redaction. In the overall process of analysis Justice Canada had sought detailed information in a questionnaire form from the country’s 13 provinces and territories about the potential ratification and implementation of the instrument.

A final response was elicited from Justice Canada on 29 October 2018, which provided the Canada OPCAT Project with a highly truncated and redacted copy of its OPCAT legal analysis. Of this 281 page-report some 240 pages were withheld, while a further 41 released pages were significantly redacted, offering limited insights into the on-going ratification process in the country. The Canada OPCAT Project released a critical statement about this response.

Even so, through the issuing of analogue Access to Information Requests with different provinces and territories individual responses to Justice Canada’s questions were obtained. It should be noted, however, that certain provinces blankly refused to do so, or provided highly redacted responses.

Will it be any different this time regarding the current Access to Information and Privacy Request with Global Affairs Canada? For this answer, please follow these pages closely in the coming weeks.


Find out more about Canada’s OPCAT ratification process here.

Conversely, find out more about Australia’s more open and inclusive OPCAT implementation process in this series of different articles (please click on the three preceding links).